US Navy

Global Shipbuilding Strategy Must Include Foreign Investment for Frigate Fleet

A foreign shipbuilder should invest in a dedicated new American yard for frigate construction, according to William Toti, the nominee for US Navy Under Secretary.

4 min readMarine Insight
Global Shipbuilding Strategy Must Include Foreign Investment for Frigate Fleet
Image for representation purposes only

Building warships in the United States is a national-security imperative, but the way we build them is a strategic liability. William Toti, the nominee for Navy Under Secretary, told senators that the quickest path to a modern frigate fleet is a new American shipyard financed by a foreign builder, a proposal that deserves serious consideration, not reflexive rejection. His testimony cuts to a core problem: American shipyards build the best ships in the world, but they do not build them in the best way. That distinction matters more than ever as the Navy grapples with a fleet stretched thin, a reality underscored by the recent departure of the USS George Washington from the Middle East, leaving just two carriers in the region. The pressure on hulls is measurable, and it is not sustainable.

Toti's plan is not an endorsement of offshoring. He explicitly told Senator Angus King that he no longer supports building warships in foreign yards, a shift from his earlier support for a model similar to the Coast Guard's icebreaker program, which simultaneously builds vessels in Finland, Texas, and Louisiana. Instead, he is arguing for an integrated approach: bring foreign capital and world-class production processes to American soil, and build a yard dedicated exclusively to frigates. The logic is empirical. Existing U.S. yards are old, their infrastructure limited, and their processes held back by decades of constrained investment. A new yard built from scratch, financed by a partner that already does world-class work, could deliver frigates faster than retrofitting legacy facilities. This is not about replacing American capacity, it is about adding calibrated, purpose-built capacity where it is needed most. The Navy's own data shows that destroyers are currently doing the work of frigates, a mismatch that wastes high-end capability on missions that do not require it. A dedicated frigate yard would correct that imbalance.

The political headwinds are real. All four congressional defense committees have moved to block purchases of warships built in foreign yards, and lawmakers from both parties have criticized the approach. Senator Rick Scott of Florida was direct: warships must be built in the United States. Toti's proposal answers that demand, the ships would be built here, just with foreign investment and expertise. This is not an abdication of sovereignty; it is a pragmatic acknowledgment that the U.S. industrial base cannot scale fast enough on its own. The Navy is reportedly considering an international competition for a new frigate class, which could bring European and Asian designs into the mix. That competition would be meaningless without a yard capable of executing those designs efficiently. Toti's proposal provides the infrastructure to make that competition real. Meanwhile, other navies are not waiting. The Validated Defence Upgrade Strengthens Naval Readiness with Integrated Missile Systems signed by India demonstrates how quickly allied nations are modernizing their naval capabilities with integrated, peer-reviewed systems. The U.S. risks falling behind not in technology, but in throughput.

The specific consequence to watch is whether Toti can convince the Senate that foreign investment in a domestic yard is distinct from foreign construction. If he does, the next question is which foreign shipbuilder will commit the capital, and what design they will bring. The answer will shape the frigate fleet for decades. That is not a detail to observe from a distance, it is a decision point that will determine whether the Navy gets the ships it needs on a timeline that matches the threat.

From Marine Insight

The US Navy’s nominee for Under Secretary William Toti has said that a foreign shipbuilder should invest in a brand-new shipyard in the United States that would build only frigates for the service.

He made the remarks before the Senate Armed Services Committee on November 19, 2026, during a hearing held for his nomination to the Navy’s second civilian post.

Read the original at Marine Insight